hate crime legislation?
4 May 2007 10:15![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
jrtomThis is an entirely serious question, and I'd appreciate some responses.
I don't understand the reason why the category 'hate crime' exists as a legal term. I'm fully in favor of anti-discrimination laws, and I believe that people get beaten up, or worse, for being (say) gay on an unfortunately regular basis.
What I don't understand is why such crimes cannot be effectively addressed under existing statutes. Why does it matter, in law, what reason someone has (or asserts) for beating the mortal crap out of someone else?
I mean, I can understand taking the motivation into account in terms of the kind of sentence that you give--community service for an appropriate support organization or charity might be especially appropriate. But I really don't see why differences in motivation define different crimes.
If anyone here can provide some cogent arguments for why hate crime legislation needs to exist, I'd really like to hear them; I'm prepared to believe that there's something I'm missing.
I don't understand the reason why the category 'hate crime' exists as a legal term. I'm fully in favor of anti-discrimination laws, and I believe that people get beaten up, or worse, for being (say) gay on an unfortunately regular basis.
What I don't understand is why such crimes cannot be effectively addressed under existing statutes. Why does it matter, in law, what reason someone has (or asserts) for beating the mortal crap out of someone else?
I mean, I can understand taking the motivation into account in terms of the kind of sentence that you give--community service for an appropriate support organization or charity might be especially appropriate. But I really don't see why differences in motivation define different crimes.
If anyone here can provide some cogent arguments for why hate crime legislation needs to exist, I'd really like to hear them; I'm prepared to believe that there's something I'm missing.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
10%
Date: 5 May 2007 04:54 (UTC)That would be, what, like, 8 billion a year?
Okay, pick 10 projects at that scale. Seriously. It's late and I'm bitter.
1. Vaccinate all kids everywhere, worldwide. For what? Everything. It's in the noise.
2. Universal health care.
3. Universal health care.
4. Universal health care. (feel free to move items off the bottom if we need more).
5. 800,000 college scholarships. $10k each.
6. Each state gets 160 million to spend on "core issues"
7. 80,000 small business loans. $100k each.
8. $8 billion for HIV research. Let's end this shit.
9. $8 billion into Sustainable energy.
10. $8 billion into doctors without borders. You want to see civilization take off in the developing world? Do this. You ain't seen nothin' yet.